Read Our Reviews from Top Rated Dealer In Hanoverton, OH

Joe Graves

07/12/2026

5.00

Bought a car from the place. Awesome experience!!

LoriBeth Bowermaster

07/08/2026

5.00

They were amazing and worked with me for 4 hrs to get me approved for a car and set me up with one I could feel very safe in after getting in my car accident. Will continue going back to them when I decide to upgrade.

Gary Schuster

07/08/2026

5.00

Zach Plumley

07/08/2026

5.00

Ill be at repeat customer. Great to work with helped me get in a reliable nice car when I was in a bad situation. Quick and easy

Destiny T

07/07/2026

5.00

I couldn't be happier with my experience at New Garden Auto Mall! Our recent Hyundai purchase is in immaculate condition.Celeste and Don were fantastic to work with. They were knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely kind throughout the entire process. Car buying can be stressful, but they made it simple and enjoyable for once.Thank you both for helping me find such a great vehicle (after holding on to my 2013 for way too long!) I highly recommend New Garden Auto Mall to anyone looking for a quality used car and outstanding customer service!

Garrett Knight

07/07/2026

5.00

Five stars all the way! We had an outstanding experience buying our Hyundai from New Garden Auto Mall. The car is spotless and in amazing condition.A special thank you to Celeste and Don for going above and beyond. They were friendly, knowledgeable, and truly cared about making sure we found the right vehicle. The entire buying process was quick, easy, and completely hassle-free.We drove away feeling confident in our purchase. Thank you again!

jen balint

07/01/2026

5.00

Third vehicle from these guys!!! They are the absolute best🤗 I will never buy a vehicle from ANYWHERE else!!!! Trust.

Chantel Bell

06/25/2026

5.00

I cannot say enough good things about my experience at New Garden Auto Mall. They truly went above and beyond to help me find the right vehicle for my family's needs. Even though they didn't have exactly what I was looking for on the lot, they took the time and effort to locate a vehicle that was the perfect fit for me.What impressed me most was their dedication to making the process work when other dealerships couldn't. They worked hard to get me approved and into a reliable vehicle, and never made me feel like just another customer. Throughout the entire process, they were patient, honest, and focused on making sure I was completely happy with my purchase.Their customer service didn't stop once the paperwork was signed—they genuinely cared that I was satisfied with my vehicle and made sure all of my questions and concerns were addressed. If you're looking for a dealership that will go the extra mile and truly put customers first, I highly recommend New Garden Auto Mall. Thank you for making what could have been a stressful experience such a positive one!

kendyl daggy

06/04/2026

5.00

Everyone who works at the auto mall was so BEYOND helpful! they make sure you get all of your questions answered and help make a price you can afford! they help explain why/what everything means and make it such a easy and wonderful experience

Danielle Schuster

05/30/2026

5.00

No hassle, honest, knowledgeable are a few words that describe this business. I would and will continue to recommend this dealership. Chefs kiss 😗🤌 thank you so much for making this a wonderful experience!!!